Managing Networks in Project-Based Organisations (eBook)

Stephen Pryke, FRICS, MSc, PhD, PGCertEd, DipS, MCMI, is Professor of Supply Chain and Project Networks, Course Director of the MSc Project and Enterprise Management and Director of Postgraduate Teaching and Learning at University College London. He is also the Director of the Centre for Organisational Network Analysis (CONA@UCL). He has provided project management training and consultancy to a number of major European companies and has been a consultant with Durland Consulting in Chicago, a management consultant specialising in social network analysis.

List of Figures xi

About the Author xiii

Preface xv

Acknowledgements xvii

1 Introduction 1

Structure of the Book 2

2 Theoretical Context 11

Management Context 11

Project Transitions 12

Project Management as Practice 12

Systems Theory and Networks 13

Transient Relationships 13

Dyadic Contractual Relationships and Structure 14

Permanent and Temporary Organising 15

Structure and Networks 16

Information Classification 16

Nodes and Linkages 17

Summary 18

3 Networks and Projects 21

Definition 22

Origins and History of the Concept of Social Networks and their Analysis 22

Problems with Projects 24

Actor Role Classification and Ritualistic Behaviour 25

Routines 26

Are Networks a Response to Uncertainty in Projects? 27

Temporary Project Systems and their Replication 28

Beyond the 'Iron Triangle' 28

Why Networks? 30

Individuals and Firms in Networks 32

Problems Associated with the Use of SNA in Project Research 32

Summary 33

4 Why Networks? 35

Definition 36

Why Choose Social Network Analysis? 36

Problems Associated with the Use of SNA in Project Research 37

Concepts and Terminology 38

Defining the Population for the Study 46

What is a Network? 46

Actor Characteristics 47

Network Characteristics 55

Some Final Thoughts 56

Conclusion 58

5 Self?]Organising Networks in Projects 61

Introduction 61

What Do Project Clients Want? 63

Dangerous Assumptions 66

Implications if these Assumptions are Incorrect 69

Networks and Uncertainty 70

Does it Matter How We Conceptualise the Project? 70

Procurement Through Markets and Hierarchies; Project Design and Delivery Through Networks 71

Summary and Conclusions 73

6 Game Theory and Networks 77

Introduction 77

To Begin: Some History 78

What is a Game? 79

Key Assumptions 83

Benefits of Applying Game Theory to Project Networks 85

Other Considerations in Applying Game Theory to Project Networks 85

Choices About Actions and Co?]Players 86

Nash Equilibrium 88

Anti?]Coordination Behaviour: 'Hawk-Dove' and 'Chicken' Games 89

Game Theory and Information Exchange Network Formation 89

Game Theory and the Five Dangerous Assumptions in Projects 90

Summary and Conclusions 93

7 Network Roles and Personality Types 95

Network Roles 98

Personality Traits 104

Humour and Behaviour in Networks 104

Profiling an Ideal Project Network Actor 109

Specific Personality Traits 109

Network Roles and Personality Traits 113

Summary 115

8 Network Enabling 117

What Do We Mean by Network Enabling? 117

Trust 119

Empathy 120

Reciprocity, Favours and Psychological Contracts 123

Implications of Violation of Psychological Contracts 124

Generosity 126

Characteristics of Individuals that are Destructive for Networks 128

Narcissism 129

Egotism 130

Summary 131

9 Project Networks and Building Information Modelling 133

BIM Origins 133

Building Information Modelling and Information Management 134

Information Management and Organisation Structure 135

BIM as an Artefact 135

Self?]Organising Networks in the Context of Design 137

BIM and Networks: A Research Agenda 139

10 Introduction to the Case Studies 143

Technical Overview of Case Studies 143

Research Funding 146

Summary 146

11 Case Study 1: Communities in Self?]Organising Project Networks 147

Data Collection 148

Data Analysis 150

Findings 150

Communities in Self?]Organising Project Networks 152

Summary 154

12 Case Study 2: Dysfunctional Prominence in Self?]Organising Project Networks 157

Data Collection 157

Data Analysis 158

Actor Prominence Measures 158

Organisational Networks 160

Summary 162

13 Case Study 3: Costing Networks 165

Conceptual Framework 165

Network Costs 166

Data Analysis 167

Summary 168

14 Summary and Conclusions 171

Introduction 171

Chapter Summaries 171

Conclusions 177

Appendix 181

References 183

Index 207