Nature, Human Nature, and Human Difference

Justin E. H. Smith is university professor of the history and philosophy of science at the Universite Paris Diderot--Paris VII. He is the author of Divine Machines: Leibniz and the Sciences of Life (Princeton), coeditor and cotranslator of The Leibniz-Stahl Controversy, and a regular contributor to the New York Times and other publications.

Acknowledgments ix A Note on Citations and Terminology x Introduction 1 I.1 Nature 1 I.2 Historical Ontology 2 I.3 The History of Science and the History of Philosophy 10 I.4 Aims and Outline 17 Chapter 1: Curious Kinks 24 1.1 Essence 24 1.2 Race and Cognition 28 1.3 Race without a Theory of Essences; or, Liberal Racism 32 1.4 Constructionism and Eliminativism 38 1.5 Natural Construction 47 1.6 Conclusion 54 Chapter 2: Toward a Historical Ontology of Race 56 2.1 False Positives in the History of Race 56 2.2 "Erst Spruce, Now Rusty and Squalid" 58 2.3 Race and Dualism 64 2.4 Conclusion 68 Chapter 3: New Worlds 70 3.1 "I Had to Laugh Vehemently at Aristotle's Meteorological Philosophy" 70 3.2 America and the Limits of Philosophy 72 3.3 Native Knowledge 78 3.4 Conclusion 90 Chapter 4: The Specter of Polygenesis 92 4.1 Libertinism and Naturalism from the Sixteenth to the Eighteenth Century 92 4.2 Pre-Adamism 102 4.3 Diffusionist Models 105 4.4 Conclusion 113 Chapter 5: Diversity as Degeneration 114 5.1 The "History of Abused Nature" 114 5.2 Diet and Custom 123 5.3 Hybridism and the Threat of Ape-Human Kinship 129 5.4 Conclusion 138 Chapter 6: From Lineage to Biogeography 140 6.1 Race, Species, Breed 140 6.2 Francois Bernier's Racial Geography 143 6.3 A Gassendian Natural Philosopher in the Court of the Grand Moghul 149 6.4 Bernier and Leibniz 155 6.5 Conclusion 158 Chapter 7: Leibniz on Human Equality and Human Domination 160 7.1 Introduction 160 7.2 Chains: Leibniz on the Series Generationum 163 7.3 Chains, Continued: Leibniz on Slavery 170 7.4 The Science of Singular Things 183 7.5 Mapping the Diversity of the Russian Empire 187 7.6 Conclusion: Diversity without Race 202 Chapter 8: Anton Wilhelm Amo 207 8.1 "The Natural Genius of Africa" 207 8.2 Amo's Legacy 215 8.3 The Impassivity of the Human Mind 221 8.4 Conclusion: From Philippi to Kant 227 Chapter 9: Race and Its Discontents in the Enlightenment 231 9.1 Introduction 231 9.2 The Significance of Skin Color 235 9.3 Kant: From Non Sequitur to Critique? 241 9.4 J. G. Herder: The Expectation of Brotherhood 248 9.5 J. F. Blumenbach: Variety without Plurality 252 Conclusion 264 Biographical Notes 269 Bibliography 273 Index 293