Ethics and Analogy (Qiyās) in 5th/11th Century Islamic Legal Theory

In Ethics and Analogy Opwis traces the 5th/11th century shift in Islamic legal theory toward understanding the purpose of God’s law as attaining people’s maṣlaḥa in this life, which enables extending the law outside of Scripture and Ashʿarī legal universalism.

---

In Ethics and Analogy (Qiyās) in 5th/11th Century Islamic Legal Theory Felicitas Opwis presents how ʿAbd al-Jabbār, Abū l-Ḥusayn al-Baṣrī, al-Dabbūsī, al-Shīrāzī, and al-Juwaynī relate the ethical status of acts to their legal norm, and whether they apply the ethical content of divine rulings in the procedure of analogy when extending laws to new circumstances. The study draws attention to theological worldview as an explanatory factor of norm construction and a jurist’s approach to identifying the ratio legis of divine rulings. The book traces the shift, fully articulated later by al-Ghazālī, toward understanding the purpose of the divine law as attaining people’s maṣlaḥa in this life, which enables extending the law outside of Scripture and supports Ashʿarī legal universalism.