One Life for Another (eBook)

CHAPTER 1

The young attorney sat at his desk, running a hand through his thick curly hair as he stared at the files scattered in front of him. He grabbed the Bohannon divorce file from under his half empty coffee cup and looked over the list detailing which specific items his client wanted from her marital residence: the blue couch in the living room, the small pearl mirror in the bathroom, the ten-inch purple vibrator. He grinned, shook his head and thought: The things people fight over.

The buzzing intercom jarred him from his musings. “Hey, big shot!, United States Judge Michael W. Henry’s office on line one,” said Carol, the receptionist and assistant he was economically forced to have working for him.

He reached for the phone, straightened out his back, took a deep breath, and said as calmly and articulately as he could muster, “This is Steve Hanson, Your Honor.”

“Hi, Steve, this is Gail with Judge Henry’s office.” He relaxed into his chair. “I will patch you through to His Honor in just a second. But tell me, real quick, how have you been?”

“Doing well, Gail, and what about you?”

“I’m good, although we still miss you around here. I know it has only been a little over four months, but it’s felt like forever. Even the judge said he was glad this case came up because it gave him an excuse to give you a call. I’m going to put you on hold while I get His Honor on the phone.”

Steve was just getting into the piano version of U2’s “One” when the line picked up.

“Steve, Judge Henry here. How is your practice going?”

“Very well, Your Honor. I’m doing mostly divorces, misdemeanors, and small claims right now. It is not all that glamorous, but it pays the bills, and it is actually kind of fun most days. I honestly feel like I am helping people through their toughest times, which makes up for the fact that most of them usually can’t afford to pay me much.”

“That’s true; anyone who loves practicing law at the street level does it more for the sense of helping others than the fees charged. But it is also the best way to become a great trial lawyer. Those cases give you the courtroom experience you need to be able to handle the bigger cases later in your career.”

“Yes, Your Honor.” Steve smiled. “I remember you saying that to many young lawyers at different events during the two years I worked for you.”

“I’m glad you are finding your way in the world of being a solo practitioner. However, that is not the purpose of my call. I just received a new capital habeas appeal file on my docket, and I was wondering if you would accept an appointment to represent the appellant in this matter, one Scottie Wayne Pinkerton. The case originated in Rogers County, Oklahoma.”

“Yes, I would be honored to help sir,” said Steve, deferentially.

“Glad to hear it. I will sign this order, and as soon as we hang up, Gail will get it filed in the clerk’s office and email you a copy. After the appointment is official, you’ll need to contact Sam Parker, the attorney who represented Mr. Pinkerton on his state court appeals. She will provide you the boxes containing everything that has been gathered over the last seven years for Mr. Pinkerton’s defense. From there, you are on your own. I expect you not to let me down on this case. I know you will give him the quality representation our constitution confers upon all the individuals facing our nation’s harshest punishment. Good luck with your law practice, I’m glad to hear you are enjoying it, goodbye.”

Steve barely got out, “Thank you, Your Honor. Goodbye,” before the line clicked dead on the other end. After Steve hung up the phone, his stomach tightened. I am actually going to be representing someone on death row, he thought. A convicted murderer whose life or death will now be determined by the quality of my representation.

A wave of anxiety swept over him. He thought about the challenges that now faced him. He would have to go to death row and meet Scottie in person. He would have to write a 100–120-page brief on Scottie’s behalf. Someday, he would have to argue in front of a three-judge panel at the United States Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals in Denver, Colorado and, one day, possibly argue his case in front of the nine justices who made up the United States Supreme Court.

If he were unsuccessful at all levels of the appeal, he would have to spend Scottie’s last twenty-four hours with him. He would watch the prison officials escort Scottie, someone he would have known for years by that point, into the execution chamber. Watch the prison guards strap his client to a gurney as the nurse stuck a needle into Scottie’s arm. Watch the tubes deliver the statutory doses of the government-approved pharmaceuticals created to end a man’s life in a manner that was theoretically not cruel or unusual. And then sit in the viewing room and watch his friend die, knowing he had failed him. Steve wondered how he would handle that. He made an oath to himself to never have to find out.

Carol, a sixty-two-year-old redhead from rural Oklahoma with a voice and attitude reminiscent of Flo from Alice, opened the door to his office, startling Steve out of his grim daydream. “What did that highfalutin’ federal judge want with a little baby lawyer like you?” Carol quipped.

“He was calling to appoint me to represent Scottie Pinkerton, a death row inmate, on his federal capital punishment habeas appeal- you probably don’t know but that is the last appeal death row inmates get before they are executed.”

“Shiiiiit, you barely know how to draw up a legally binding divorce decree, let alone find the clerk’s office at the courthouse. Why in the hell would any federal judge appoint you to such a muy importante’ case?”

“Before I got an office here, I spent two years working as a law clerk on death penalty cases at the federal courthouse. I did nothing but that type of work every day. I worked side-by-side with all three federal judges in the Northern District of Oklahoma Courthouse.” Steve’s back straightened and chest involuntarily swelled as he listed off the details of his previous work with growing confidence, “So, although I have only handled divorces for two months, I dealt exclusively with death penalty jurisprudence for two years and I know it inside and out.”

“That’s nice, but don’t they usually appoint attorneys who have been doin’ this shit for several years to those cases?”

“Yes. But all three presiding judges at the federal court decided my work experience there qualified me for appointments. And now one of them has appointed me to be the only thing standing between Scottie Pinkerton and death.” He smiled proudly as he said this last sentence, thinking of all the times Carol had made him feel ignorant and unqualified over the last 134 days.

She turned without another word and brusquely walked out of the room.

Ever since Steve started practicing at the office, she had treated him like a moron. In the beginning, she did know more than he did about divorce procedure and other simple tasks, like how to file a pleading at the courthouse. Yet even when he gradually learned how to do this work himself, her attitude remained unchanged. But for once, he was able to show that his legal training and experience meant something in this world, whether she believed it or not. Steve wondered why he should even care about Carol’s opinions as he hummed the theme song to Alice to himself. “There’s a new girl in town…”

As he basked in his small victory against Carol, the realization that he had just been given a highly important appointment crept back into his psyche. Steve was now Scottie’s last chance at avoiding the execution table. Scottie’s life was dependent on Steve’s legal acumen and diligence; he knew that he would have to put every ounce of his energy and intelligence into the fight before him. He closed the Bohannon file and took a another swig of his coffee.

When he called Parker’s office to find out when he could get the case file, her assistant answered the phone. “Oh, the Scottie Pinkerton file… yeah, that’s a tough one. You’re taking that on? Good luck to you. I’ll give Sam the message.”

Steve hung up and started searching the internet for background information about the case. He entered “Scottie Pinkerton murder Rogers County Oklahoma” into the search engine, and within seconds, several links to news articles filled his screen. He selected a few and read them over. The facts looked to be as helpful as a mace in a tickling contest.

To be exact, it may have been the worst facts for a defendant Steve had ever read since he’d started in the death penalty business.

The articles painted the picture of an abusive husband who finally went too far. It was a classic tale of despair and heartbreak. One article laid out the amount of uncontroverted evidence against Scottie in twenty-three bullet points; the worst of which stated that, according to all reports, 911 received a call approximately five minutes before Ashley Pinkerton was found dead by a local sheriff’s deputy wherein she reported that her husband had just hit her and he was still in their home.

Thirty minutes after her lifeless body was found in their living room, Scottie was arrested with scratches on his face apparently caused by his wife in self-defense. DNA reports confirmed the skin under her fingernails belonged to him. Additionally, there were bloody footprints in the house. The tread matched a pair of his tennis shoes. The shoes were found covered in...